Skip to content
personpersonBhushan AgharkarBhushan AgharkarPsychiatrist board-certified in adult and forensic psychiatry.← All People
Expert witness

Bhushan Agharkar

Courtroom still of Bhushan Agharkar.

Psychiatrist board-certified in adult and forensic psychiatry.

240 lines·9 proceedings·5 mentions

About

Bhushan Agharkar testified for the defense on Day 18 as an expert in Adult and Forensic Psychiatry. He said his assessment of Timothy Jones found schizophrenia and a minor neurocognitive disorder, after considering records, interviews, family history, symptoms, traumatic brain injury, and testing.

Agharkar testified that the condition was not substance-induced and was not being faked. The court redesignated his materials list and report as Court's Exhibits 88 and 89 for identification rather than admitting them as defense exhibits.

The State cross-examined Agharkar about the limits of his diagnosis, his defense retention, the length of his interviews, and his reliance on Jones's self-reported history and other records. He said he was not offering a criminal-responsibility opinion and addressed questions concerning spice use, Geodon, cognitive testing, a prior brain injury, and Chantix. The court sustained a defense objection to the word "murder" and limited further Chantix questioning to whether Agharkar had information connecting it to this case.

Key Points

Trial Record (9)

Trial 12019 Murder TrialApr 29, 2019 โ€“ Jun 13, 2019Called by defense

Bhushan Agharkar testified for the defense on Day 18 as an Adult and Forensic Psychiatry expert, diagnosing Timothy Jones with schizophrenia and a minor neurocognitive disorder. The State challenged the basis and limits of that assessment on cross-examination.

Day 16

Day 18

DirectBhushan Agharkar โ€” DirectBhushan AgharkarCasey Secor4highlights106lines spoken

Summary

Dr. Agharkar testified that his assessment found schizophrenia and brain injury, rejected substance-induced psychosis, and had two defense materials marked as court exhibits.

Highlights (4)

Quoteโ€œSo based on my assessment, he suffers from schizophrenia as well as what's called a minor neuro-cognitive disorder, that's just a fancy term for brain damage.โ€— Bhushan AgharkarStates the expert's central diagnostic conclusion.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
CrossBhushan Agharkar โ€” CrossBhushan AgharkarSuzanne Mayes4highlights134lines spoken

Summary

The State tested Dr. Agharkar's diagnosis, sources, and medication analysis; the court limited Chantix questioning after a defense objection.

Highlights (4)

testimony highlightDr. Agharkar confirmed that he did not perform a criminal-responsibility evaluation and was not offering an opinion about whether Timothy Jones knew right from wrong at the time of the killings.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quoteโ€œFor the most part, yes, about psychiatric symptoms, yes, and describing his past history. There were things he could not recall. There were things he was not able to fill in for me. And that does happen, but I never thought he was lying to me about those things.โ€— Bhushan AgharkarExplains the expert's qualified reliance on Timothy Jones's self-reported psychiatric history despite acknowledged gaps.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quoteโ€œNo, I would certainly consider it and I did consider it. But I'm saying sometimes -- sometimes you see effects from the injury immediately, sometimes they may take five, ten years to present, so it really just depends. What I'm saying to you is you're using the wrong test to measuring functioning. By implying that somehow academic testing equals no brain damage is false, that's not an accurate statement. So that's what I'm trying to -- that's not right.โ€— Bhushan AgharkarDr. Agharkar rejected the premise that academic testing alone could rule out effects from a brain injury.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
confrontationThe cross-examination tested Dr. Agharkar's reliance on records and an interview of Chrystal Ballentine, whom he had not personally interviewed.Open in transcript →

Day 19

Day 24