Skip to content
2019 Murder TrialtranscripttranscriptJacquelyn Moran — Direct/Cross - Day 28 - 2019 Murder TrialJacquelyn Moran, Eli Jones's former first-grade teacher, described his classroom work and school-year relationship with him, then recalled a school family night he attended with his father.
Suzanne MayesRobert MadsenEugene C. Griffith, Jr.Jacquelyn MoranCourt ClerkJacquelyn MoranTHE COURTSuzanne MayesRobert Madsendirectcross
9 pages·5 witnesses·967 lines
School witnesses testified about Eli and Nahtahn Jones before the State rested and the defense began presenting mitigation evidence.
Jacquelyn Moran — Direct
DirectDirectJacquelyn Moran — Direct Jacquelyn Moran Suzanne Mayes

JACQUELYN MORAN, being first duly sworn, testified as follows:

237:54

COURT CLERK: Have a seat over there, please. If you will state your name, spell your last for the record.

338:10

JACQUELYN MORAN: Jacquelyn Moran, M-O-R-A-N.

438:13

THE COURT: How do you spell your first?

JACQUELYN MORAN: J-A-C-Q-U-E-L-Y-N.

DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MS. MAYES:

838:22

SUZANNE MAYES: Good morning, Ms. Moran.

938:23

JACQUELYN MORAN: Good morning.

1038:25

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to start by asking you to tell us a little bit about yourself.

1138:29

JACQUELYN MORAN: I work at Saxe Gotha Elementary School. I'm currently a kindergarten teacher. This is my first year in kindergarten. I've been there for seven years. And before I was in kindergarten, I taught first grade.

1238:40

SUZANNE MAYES: All right. Tell us a little bit about your educational training that led you to become a public school teacher?

1338:46

JACQUELYN MORAN: I attended the University of South Carolina and got a degree in early childhood education. I did my internship at Saxe Gotha Elementary and couldn't leave.

1438:58

SUZANNE MAYES: Okay. Ms. Moran, how is it that you knew Eli Jones?

1539:04

JACQUELYN MORAN: Eli was in my first grade class in 2013.

1639:11

SUZANNE MAYES: All right. And you had him the whole school year?

1739:14

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am.

1839:15

SUZANNE MAYES: Take us through that. Tell us a little bit about Eli as a child.

1939:20

JACQUELYN MORAN: Eli was all boy. He was sweet. He loved superheros. But what I remember about Eli was he was everybody's friend. Everyone loved to be friends with Eli. He was the kid that would play with anyone who needed someone to play with. I'm sorry. He was curious. He loved to learn. He loved school because he loved to learn. He was my little buddy.

2039:52

SUZANNE MAYES: And when you say "he was my little buddy", can you tell us a little bit about your actual relationship with him?

2140:00

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yeah. Eli and I were very, very close. That was my second year of teaching and I became very close with him. He would gravitate to the front of the carpet. He was smaller, so he, at the beginning of the year, was at the front of the carpet so he could see. But as the year progressed, he wanted to stay. Oftentimes, when I would teach at the front, he'd be right in front of me. He was one of the kids that would want to sit with me at lunch. He was special.

2240:35

SUZANNE MAYES: And Ms. Moran, were you aware that he didn't have a mother in his home?

2340:39

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am, I was. And I did, you know, take on part of that role for him. You know, morning hugs and we ate breakfast together a lot.

2440:48

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to show you some photographs.

SUZANNE MAYES: I believe all of these are going to be entered in evidence without objection, Your Honor.

2741:04

ROBERT MADSEN: Yes, Your Honor.

2841:06

THE COURT: All right.

2941:14

SUZANNE MAYES: First grade school year. This is 256, that would be the school year of 2013 to 2014, so that would be the fall and the spring before the murder?

3041:33

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am. And he is in the front row right there in the green shirt. And that was me a couple of years ago.

3141:45

SUZANNE MAYES: All right. Let me show you 297.

3241:53

JACQUELYN MORAN: That would have been his yearbook photo. They would come and take pictures in the fall. That actually would have been taken before the class picture.

3342:05

SUZANNE MAYES: Now, one of the things that you did as a teacher is you documented certain aspects of daily classroom activity?

3442:18

JACQUELYN MORAN: They were my babies. I took a lot of pictures.

SUZANNE MAYES: Let me show you some of those photographs now. And if you could, just kind of take us through what you remember about these particular days and what's happening. I'm going to start with 266 here.

3642:38

JACQUELYN MORAN: This was a day when we had careers come and this was a firefighter, a real life hero, who came to visit the classroom. Let me see if I can use this. This is Eli right here right at the front. You can see, you know, where he's sitting. This is usually the spot he chose because I would be at the front teaching at the board. So watching all of that, real firefighter.

3743:08

SUZANNE MAYES: And you mentioned he liked superheros?

3943:10

SUZANNE MAYES: Is it surprising to you that he's standing there -- or he's sitting there with the firefighter?

4043:14

JACQUELYN MORAN: Not at all. Not at all.

4143:20

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to show you what is State's 267.

4243:28

JACQUELYN MORAN: We had an initiative at school, Esteem, and it was incorporating engineering and mathematics. And we had a robotics team come into the classroom just to give that experience to kids. And he's right here. I don't know if you can zoom into his face, but he is in awe of that robot. It would have been like remote controlled. Yeah.

4343:57

SUZANNE MAYES: All right. Now, let me show you what is 268.

4443:59

JACQUELYN MORAN: One thing that we do at school is a time where they don't just read to themselves, they read, you know, with a friend. So you can see in this picture -- and he's right here in this green shirt. He's reading with a buddy during read to partner time. I like the way that he's like pointing to the words and trying to show his friend, trying to help. That's what he did. He was a friend. He would try to help anyone who needed it.

4544:31

SUZANNE MAYES: And when you say that he was a friend, tell us about that in terms of the rest of the class.

4644:31

JACQUELYN MORAN: Everyone loved Eli. He was a popular selection. At reading time when they would pick a buddy, he usually was in charge of the shadow tag game that they would play. That was the year that they loved to play tag, but, you know, at school, you don't touch. So they would play shadow tag and he was definitely a ring leader in that. He actually was a really good artist and one of the things that he did as a friend is he would try to teach other people how to draw like him. All right. Well, there he is. That's his -- that's his classic -- that's a classic Eli grin. That's usually -- when you were teaching, that's usually what you were getting. That was the sweet smile. That's the one I remember. And this would have been a buddy time. On that table, that's a leadership notebook. And we had what was called leadership buddies. Y'all have heard about the leadership notebooks some. And their buddies would come and help them with their leadership notebook because they were barely reading, barely writing. They would come and help them learn how to present them to people or add things to their folder. And he actually -- I always had to correct him. He would call his leadership buddy his big brother.

4745:59

SUZANNE MAYES: Even when you corrected him, did he continue to call him --

4846:04

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yeah. Yeah. He was stuck on that. He would tell me, No, that's my big brother.

5046:16

JACQUELYN MORAN: This is him right here. This was a group project we actually did with another class. A fifth grade class came down and they were doing like an animal research project. And they were turning it into like an IMovie, learning about technology and how to use Ipads. And they each had a group and they had a group of fifth graders that were helping them learn how to do that. We did a lot of group work with classes outside of my class. People that were -- or kids that were older or kids that had skills they didn't have. Our school is a whole community.

5146:56

SUZANNE MAYES: Let me show what is 271, and you take us through what is happening in this photo. You're taking all of these photos?

5247:01

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes. This was either Red Ribbon week or Dr. Suess week. Those weeks, we always do a crazy sock day. So this would have been a crazy sock day. And this is a classic teacher picture for crazy sock day when they all put their feet in. He's right there on the corner.

5347:23

SUZANNE MAYES: All right. And then 272 that goes along with this?

5447:28

JACQUELYN MORAN: This is the exact same moment, but I went to the other side of the room because you couldn't see all of their faces. So he's actually down here in this corner smiling back at the camera with his crazy socks. At the front of the room.

5647:48

JACQUELYN MORAN: A moment ago when I talked about group work, this is also that same project they were working on. I like to document their lives and what they do and send it -- send it home so everyone knows what we're working on. You can see him right here. He's diligently working on whatever part was his.

5848:14

JACQUELYN MORAN: He's up here in the corner. I really don't remember what they're doing in that picture, but they're definitely working together on something.

6048:25

JACQUELYN MORAN: When I talk about him being curious, this is what I'm talking about. He just wanted to know stuff. Those are lima beans. This is another classic teacher thing. If you soak them long enough and you pop them open, you can see the sprouts on the inside and you can -- you can see him here investigating with his magnifying glass the inside of those lima beans.

6149:05

SUZANNE MAYES: Is this the Eli you remember?

6249:18

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes -- yes, ma'am. These are all my classroom. He's laying on the floor and who's know what they're working on. Oh, it was probably the same day. One thing we teach in first grade is about measurement. And they had cut out an item that was the same size as their foot and we were talking about how small foots take more and big foots take less. And there he is measuring the length of the room.

6349:50

SUZANNE MAYES: By foot? By his foot?

6449:50

JACQUELYN MORAN: By his foot. And he had -- he would have had a small foot. So his foot would have probably been half of the kid next to him.

6549:57

SUZANNE MAYES: Do you see anything else in this photo of Eli that you recognize?

6650:03

JACQUELYN MORAN: I believe that back here -- he loved superheros. It's hard to remember back that far, but, likely, this was his book bag at the time. He loved Spiderman. He loved Batman. Yeah.

6750:21

SUZANNE MAYES: The last photo is 277.

6850:34

JACQUELYN MORAN: I talked to you about read to partner time, but it doesn't always work out perfectly because we have odd numbers. So this would have been a lot of groups of two. And there's a picture, it's very hard to see, but he's over here. And this is actually a group of three. And he was everyone's friend. Eli would have been the person that if there was a kid left out, he would have said hey, come read with us. He didn't want anyone to feel left out. He included all. So down here, you can see he's reading with two other kids as a group of three.

6951:10

SUZANNE MAYES: It's supposed to be a group of two?

7051:12

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am.

7151:14

SUZANNE MAYES: But if there was an extra student --

7351:17

SUZANNE MAYES: -- it would be Eli that would --

7451:18

JACQUELYN MORAN: Oh, he would always volunteer. He was everyone's friend, so he could get along no matter what with who it was.

7551:40

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to show you for identification what is already in evidence as Defendant's 13 and ask you if you recognize that notebook?

7651:47

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am. This is our writing notebook that they keep at school that we do during writing time. This was his writing notebook the year I had him as a first grader.

7751:57

SUZANNE MAYES: Do you recognize his handwriting as well?

7852:00

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am. This is his handwriting.

7952:02

SUZANNE MAYES: For ID only, I'm going to show you what is State's 265 and ask you if that's a duplicate of that same item?

8052:12

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am.

8152:13
8252:14

JACQUELYN MORAN: Would you like for me to read what's here or you going to put it up?

8352:17

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to see if we can get this on the overhead here. And what do the -- what do the kids do with the writing notebooks?

8452:30

JACQUELYN MORAN: We, you know, teach during writing time different components, informational stories. I see the top of this page is "All About". And that is a unit we do in first grade, we do All About. So I would teach them a lesson on whatever our topic was and then they would have some private reflection time that they would take their idea I gave them and go write. So he would have taken an All About lesson that I modeled and then gone back to his writing time and done this. They do this independently.

8553:01

SUZANNE MAYES: What does it say?

8653:05

JACQUELYN MORAN: At the top, it says, All About My Brother. And there's a little boy saying, Can I have it? And the other one says, Yes. And at the bottom, it says: I love Tahn because he gives me things to play with and he gives stuff that I want. God, thank you for making my brother -- or thank you for my brother. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You did a wonderful job making my brother. I love God.

8753:39

SUZANNE MAYES: So that writing was about Nahtahn?

8953:45

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to ask you to take a moment.

9053:53

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, thank you.

9153:55

SUZANNE MAYES: And then when you're ready, if you can, tell us a little bit more about the leadership notebook.

9254:12

JACQUELYN MORAN: Okay. The leadership notebook is something that every student has at our school. And we really try to include things in there that are personal to them, celebrations that they had, goals that they're trying to achieve. It's something that they do that is them. They have what they want to be. How they feel about, you know, certain aspects of school. I mean, we keep a lot of data in them so that they can go back and reflect on how much they've grown through the year.

9354:44

SUZANNE MAYES: And Your Honor, if Ms. Moran may step down?

9454:50

THE COURT: You may.

9554:51

SUZANNE MAYES: Just take us through some of the contents of Eli's notebook. Do you recognize it as Eli's?

9655:01

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am.

9755:02

SUZANNE MAYES: This will be State's 255.

9855:05

JACQUELYN MORAN: This is one of Eli's superheros that he would have wanted to have taught other kids. That's his mission statement. So their mission statement is something they come up with of what they want to be. And he says, I will do my best all the time. They have goals that they would set for themselves, the things that they wanted to work on. He wanted to work on tally marks.

9955:48

SUZANNE MAYES: And what are tally marks?

10055:50

JACQUELYN MORAN: In math class, it's the ones where you have sticks of five with the cross over. And that's the first grade standard. His personal goal was, I work on my homework. These were different -- we would sit in a circle often and do what's called a seminar, where they kind of talk to each other about something that we've discussed. So that's all data on things like that.

10156:18

SUZANNE MAYES: Okay. Take us through this leadership roles I've had through the year. And I see a lot of different activities here for Eli. Take us through what these different activities are.

10256:30

JACQUELYN MORAN: Okay. So they have to sign up for jobs they think they would be good at, and I make them tell me why. And then I select each week who's going to do what. He's got that he was the line leader, so that's the coveted position. They all want to be first. The door holder, holding the door when we got out. The caboose, which would have been the last person at the end of the line. The messenger, the teacher's assistant. We've got room inspector, the class blogger, which would have kept track of everything we did that day.

10356:59

SUZANNE MAYES: There are dates beside all of these that Eli served that role in your class?

10457:01

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes. If it is colored and the date's beside it, that's the week that he got to do it.

10557:07

SUZANNE MAYES: What else do you see?

10657:10

JACQUELYN MORAN: Water counter. That was another favorite. This was his favorite. I am the line leader because I do hip and lip everyday, and there he is doing hip and lip.

JACQUELYN MORAN: That's this. This is how the kindergarten and first graders walk down the hallway.

10957:32

SUZANNE MAYES: That's what's meant by hip and lip. We're going to take a look here at some of his celebrations. If you could tell us a little bit about that.

11057:43

JACQUELYN MORAN: This would have been -- Ms. Ricard signed this for engaging respectfully. And it was in March of 2013. He would have gotten that at a lead rally. Being recognized for doing something that was respectful. This is given at the end of his kindergarten year. This is his kindergarten award. He got the Mr. Goodbar award for always being a friend. And then this one is -- I gave him this one at the end of the year. This would have been the last week of school. And it was the M&M award for being marvelous and mighty.

11158:29

SUZANNE MAYES: State's 264 and 263. I'm going to ask you about this. It's already in evidence as a Defense Exhibit. This is Defense 13. It's called All About Me, Myself and I. And if you recognize Eli's writing in some of these contents?

11258:46

JACQUELYN MORAN: That's Eli's writing, yes. My favorite game is a DS because it is fun. It's got my favorite book is Batman because it is cool. I am cute and super because I am working hard. I'm fast because I run fast.

11359:05

SUZANNE MAYES: So it's to describe three things about yourself?

11459:06

JACQUELYN MORAN: Uh-huh. This would have been like, you know, the beginning of the school year trying to understand, you know, who you are, get to know each other. That would have been him as a baby.

11559:26

SUZANNE MAYES: Do you recognize Eli's writing on this? This is Defendant's Exhibit 42.

11659:32

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes. And I actually remember him sharing that with me.

11759:36

SUZANNE MAYES: He brought this to you to show it to you?

11859:37

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yeah. We had a share time at the end of the day, that's one of the things he shared. Because I remember the string, it was so interesting.

11959:45

SUZANNE MAYES: Can you take us through that?

12059:48

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yeah. It says, God is happy. Oh, I've got them out of order. Okay. Page 1. I like the Lord because he is not mean. He is sweet. He is almighty. The Maker. Page 2 says, He made the moon after the earth. He made the sun after the moon. Do you love God?

1211:00:21

SUZANNE MAYES: I'll show you a kindergarten item with 5K on it from Eli. He went to kindergarten at Saxe Gotha before he came to you?

1221:00:30

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes, ma'am.

1231:00:31

SUZANNE MAYES: Take us through this.

1241:00:32

JACQUELYN MORAN: All right. Well, there's his little picture. He was a great artist. Obviously, he loved his field day. Okay. It says, I like to play in my box. I like to read in school all day. I like to learn the seven habits, which is part of our leader in me. I like to learn the seven habits all day. The butterfly lands on my finger at school and it loves me. I like PE and I like my teacher. The end.

1251:01:06

SUZANNE MAYES: This will be State's 288. My Year in First. Your class?

1261:01:14

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yes. We did that at the end of the year together just to help them remember their whole year. So if you go through it, it will just have different things like what his first grade favorites are, who he liked to eat lunch with, what he liked to eat, all about his school.

1271:01:30

SUZANNE MAYES: What does he say about his lunch?

1281:01:33

JACQUELYN MORAN: My favorite lunch in first grade is pizza. And then he's got his little lunch buddies down here. It's his little group of friends, Noah and Conner and Sebastian. And you can see his cute little --

1291:01:46
1301:01:47

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yeah. He was so great at drawing.

1311:01:50

SUZANNE MAYES: And in the picture of them at lunch, did he draw pizza?

1321:01:54

JACQUELYN MORAN: He did. They're all holding pizza and looking happy.

1331:01:55

SUZANNE MAYES: All right. My teacher.

1341:01:59

JACQUELYN MORAN: Well, there we are. We're holding hands.

1351:02:01

SUZANNE MAYES: He drew a picture of the two of you holdings hands?

1361:02:05

JACQUELYN MORAN: My first grade teacher's name is Ms. Moran. One thing I'll never forget about Ms. Moran -- I'm sorry -- is she's the best teacher ever. I wish I had Ms. Moran to teach next year. My teacher made me smile by the door when we would be shaking hands.

1371:02:26

SUZANNE MAYES: Is that something you recall every morning with him?

1381:02:38

JACQUELYN MORAN: Yeah. I greet my students at the door.

1391:02:50

SUZANNE MAYES: Thank you. You may return to your seat.

(Witness returns to the witness stand.)

1411:03:04

SUZANNE MAYES: Ms. Moran, did he talk about his favorite subjects and what he wanted to do when he grew up in that first grade?

1421:03:13

JACQUELYN MORAN: He did. Can I read it?

1431:03:17
1441:03:18

JACQUELYN MORAN: Okay. It says, My favorite subject is health because we can be a doctor and we can fix people.

1451:03:33

SUZANNE MAYES: And State's 310?

1461:03:37

JACQUELYN MORAN: That's in my classroom. The kids who he said he liked to eat lunch with in his book are actually the kids in this picture. This is him on the end. That was -- I see parents in the room, flowers in the background, I'm guessing that was about the last day of school probably. That was probably the day of our celebration.

1471:04:00

SUZANNE MAYES: Ms. Moran, given your relationship with Eli, is it possible to express how this crime has impacted you personally?

1481:04:18

JACQUELYN MORAN: This is something that I struggle with, I struggle daily. I see his friends. It's hard. Some days are easier, but he's always there. It's hard for me to put into words.

1491:04:44

SUZANNE MAYES: Thank you, Ms. Moran. (Whereupon, State's Exhibit numbers 255, 256, 262 through 269, 270-277, 288, 310, 332 were admitted into evidence.) (Whereupon, State's Exhibits 254, 257 through 261 were marked for identification only.)

CrossCrossJacquelyn Moran — Cross Jacquelyn Moran Robert Madsen

CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MR. MADSEN:

1511:04:55

ROBERT MADSEN: Ms. Moran, just a few questions.

1521:04:56
1531:04:58

ROBERT MADSEN: Tim came to Open House parent nights?

1541:05:04

JACQUELYN MORAN: I recall him coming to like a family night, but I don't remember the others.

1551:05:13

ROBERT MADSEN: On the nights that he came, though, Eli called those special Eli nights, didn't he?

1561:05:18

JACQUELYN MORAN: There was a night that he came by himself with his dad. I do remember him saying he was excited because he felt like it was very special to have that special time with just him.

1571:05:31

ROBERT MADSEN: With five kids, it's hard to get kind of one-on-one time?

1581:05:34
1591:05:35

ROBERT MADSEN: And, in fact, Eli liked it because, I guess, they went out to eat beforehand?

1601:05:39

JACQUELYN MORAN: I believe he said something like that, that he got to eat with him by himself.

1611:05:45

ROBERT MADSEN: And Eli loved that?

1621:05:47
1631:05:48

ROBERT MADSEN: That's all the questions I have.

1641:05:57

THE COURT: You may step down.

Continue to next page3.Johnathan Stone — Direct