Skip to content
2019 Murder TrialtranscripttranscriptJanet Ricard — Direct/Cross (Recall) (Part 2) - Day 27 - 2019 Murder TrialJanet Ricard continued describing Merah's school progress and memorial materials, including a yearbook tribute and video played for the jury. She then identified four defense photographs from school-related settings.
Suzanne MayesRobert MadsenEugene C. Griffith, Jr.Janet RicardSuzanne MayesJanet RicardRobert MadsenTHE COURTdirectcross
12 pages·5 witnesses·1,110 lines
Penalty-phase testimony and evidence included the Alabama recovery, conviction records, recordings, autopsy materials, and accounts from school and caregiving witnesses.
Janet Ricard — Direct Resumed
DirectDirectJanet Ricard — Direct Resumed Janet Ricard Suzanne Mayes
15:28:50

SUZANNE MAYES: And Ms. Ricard, just to continue, I believe there's one that I neglected to ask you about and that's Defense Exhibit 39 regarding Merah.

25:29:00

JANET RICARD: Yes, ma'am. That was for math and that is the same measure that I spoke of earlier of MAP where it's measured academic progress. And that shows she actually had the highest MAP gain for math as well in first grade.

35:29:16

SUZANNE MAYES: And that June 3rd, 2013, would be the last day --

45:29:19

JANET RICARD: That would have been --

55:29:19

SUZANNE MAYES: -- of that first grade school year?

65:29:21

JANET RICARD: Yes, ma'am, the end of her year with Ms. Lee.

75:29:25

SUZANNE MAYES: And you also identified what is State's 224, which is now in evidence. I'm going to ask you what is shown in this photograph and what this is from?

85:29:43

JANET RICARD: That was included in our yearbook for the school year 14/15. That was just a tribute to all three of the Jones children that we could include so that all of our students would have a memory of them. It just really kind of reflects each one of them. We didn't -- from what I remember, I don't think we had another photograph of Nahtahn because it was so early in the school year that year. You can see Merah with a very special friend of hers, a child that she enjoyed playing with an awful lot. And then Eli with a classmate, and that was just his personality. He was always explaining something. I'm sure he was telling her all about something. And then I think the little -- the other inset is probably something, a piece of work that Nahtahn had completed and we included since we didn't have another photograph. Just a memory, a tribute to those students in our yearbook so that all of our students could remember them.

95:30:55

SUZANNE MAYES: All right. And in addition to this tribute, can you tell us whether or not there was a unique tribute for the Jones children inside of your school?

105:31:05

JANET RICARD: We did. One of our teachers, Ms. Carolyn Still, who actually taught Eli in kindergarten, she was also a wonderful artist. So it became a goal of ours to create a space in our school where we could memorialize the children. So because they had a great fondness and love for the beach, we decided to go with a beach theme. And she created a mural that pretty much encompassed the entire learning commons throughout especially one unique area. We called it Jones Beach, had a little sign that said Jones Beach, and several other spaces that made it a very comfortable spot for our students to get a book and go read and reflect.

115:31:54

SUZANNE MAYES: In the library. I'm going to show you those photographs now, Ms. Ricard, and ask you if you can take us through what we're looking at. This is State's 226.

125:32:06

JANET RICARD: That was the sign that Ms. Still created, it just said Welcome to Jones Beach and then it has -- I think it says Seven Habits Lane, if I can read that from here.

135:32:18

SUZANNE MAYES: Seven Habits Lane, why is that unique to your school?

145:32:22

JANET RICARD: Well, because we a leader in me school and the seven habits just really drives the culture and the climate at the school. We use seven habits language throughout the day with the students to help them achieve their leadership traits and hopefully push them forward.

155:32:40

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to show you what is State's 227.

165:32:46

JANET RICARD: It's a very sentimental and special quote that Ms. Still chose to include on the wall. And then you can see along the bottom of the wall, along the walkway, there are five sets of footsteps that represent each one of the Jones children.

175:33:12
185:33:13

JANET RICARD: And that's the quote that I was speaking of. It was a quote that we chose to represent the memories that we have of the children.

195:33:27
205:33:28

JANET RICARD: That was one of the areas that we used, just kind of a little reading nook for our students to go in --

215:33:36

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to show you 230 at the same time.

225:33:38

JANET RICARD: Yeah, books were purchased and donated in memory of the students so they could go in and climb up in a boat and read books there or sit along the beach and read books.

235:33:54
245:33:55

JANET RICARD: That was another little beachy area. They could climb up in the lifeguard chair and read a book or sit along, again, the ocean area, I guess you would say.

255:34:10

SUZANNE MAYES: And why was the beach theme selected for this mural of the Jones children?

265:34:15

JANET RICARD: They always talked about loving the beach and going to the beach. When the turtle in the pocket incident happened, Eli told me he had got the turtle from the beach. So we just knew they seemed to enjoy going to the beach, so that was why that theme was selected.

275:34:37
285:34:39

JANET RICARD: That particular part of the mural was where we had decided that we would have a space to designate for the children and because we had had such a good memory of Eli and his turtle, we chose turtles to represent the children. So each one of the children were represented with a turtle and Ms. Still named each one of the turtles by one of the children's name.

295:35:23

SUZANNE MAYES: Gabriel, Eli. 234?

305:35:25

JANET RICARD: I can't read it from here. My eyes are not that grand, but again, one of the turtles were one of the children.

315:35:36
325:35:37

JANET RICARD: The same.

335:35:43
345:35:43

JANET RICARD: That looks like Nahtahn.

355:35:57

SUZANNE MAYES: Having identified what is 223, being the leadership notebook of Merah Jones that in evidence, Ms. Ricard, having been familiar with Merah for those three years, I'm going to ask you to step down and show us some of the contents of this notebook. I'm just going to ask you to keep your voice up for Joy to hear you.

365:36:22

JANET RICARD: Okay. So this was from second grade and this is one of her writings. It says, Once upon a time, there was a little zebra who lived in a beautiful castle. So I feel sure that was just the beginning of one of her writing pieces. And then her third grade year, which was the very beginning of the school year 2014/15, she had a teacher by the name of Ms. Nettles. She had begun a letter to her. It says, Dear Ms. Nettles, I am an intelligent little girl and I am scared of ghosts.

375:37:04

SUZANNE MAYES: And Ms. Ricard, you spoke of the change in Merah academically between that first grade and second grade. I'm going to show you this document and ask you to share it with us.

385:37:16

JANET RICARD: So that looks like it was what we called wildly important goals. They had -- we called it their WIG and it was just what they identified as being their goals, academic or personal goals. So you can kind of see what that looked like. And then to show her growth --

395:37:37

SUZANNE MAYES: And did she say what she wanted to do?

405:37:39

JANET RICARD: It says that her wildly important goal was, obviously, to be a ballerina. She said, I like ballet because it is important to me. It's fun.

415:37:53

SUZANNE MAYES: And then how did that change between that first grade year to her second grade year?

425:38:00

JANET RICARD: I think you can obviously see that there was great growth in writing, not only in the neatness of it, but in the volume. So for her second grade personal mission statement, which was a part of what they did in their leadership notebooks, it says, I will be a fantastic daughter. I will be a helpful sister. I will be a super student. Everyday I will do my work and make good grades. When I grow up, I want to be a nurse.

435:38:45

SUZANNE MAYES: Are you familiar with the bucket filler?

445:38:47

JANET RICARD: So her second grade teacher, a lot of what she talked about was how they could fill each other's buckets, saying kind things, being helpful to one another. So she was a bucket filler because she was loving, she was nice, she used nice words, she gave lots of hugs and she was always helping. And that describes her.

455:39:17

SUZANNE MAYES: Ms. Ricard, are there special booklets that the children do as part of their first grade year?

465:39:23

JANET RICARD: Most of the time, teachers would have like a first grade booklet or something that they could kind of remember those first few days of school or put together at the end of the year. That looks like it was one that Ms. Lee made that was probably a compilation of work over her first grade year.

475:39:38

SUZANNE MAYES: So this would be State's 338 in evidence. And if you could take us through this.

485:39:46

JANET RICARD: So that was from the first day of school. She did a picture of each of her children. So that was Merah on her first day of school and then a little poem that went along with it. She included writings.

495:40:10

SUZANNE MAYES: Can you tell us whether what you have seen in terms of what Merah has expressed truly represents her unique characteristics?

JANET RICARD: Uh-huh, absolutely.

SUZANNE MAYES: Thank you, Ms. Ricard. You may return.

(Witness returns to witness stand.)

535:40:51

SUZANNE MAYES: Ms. Ricard, can you tell us about your bond with Eli Jones?

545:41:00

JANET RICARD: I got to know Eli when he was in kindergarten. He had just a few little hiccups, just little things that we needed to work on behaviorally. He was a special little fellow and really just wanted to please, worked hard to make friends, everybody loved him. We did -- we worked on a few little things. Sometimes he'd put things in his pockets that didn't belong to him, but we always tried to turn those into teachable moments. Whenever he was in first grade, I had begun to do some Read to Succeed course work. So for one of my courses, we were asked to choose a student that would be a focus student. And I knew that was going to be difficult for me being that I was not a classroom teacher, I was an administrator, but I knew I had to fill the requirements. So I went to Ms. Muran, who was his kindergarten teacher. I had spent a lot of time in her classroom that year and I knew that Eli was having some difficulties with his reading. And since I already had such a strong relationship with him and a bond, I thought that he would be a student that I could easily work with because we would already have that rapport with one another. And I also -- I chose him because I knew that he was in a home where there were five children and I felt like he probably did not get as much help at home as he could have and I knew it was a single parent situation as well and that there was no mother in the home. So I had hoped that I could fill a little bit of that material void as well. So he and I worked together that semester. We worked on strategies that he could use in his reading and just try to go look at his reading process, what he was doing well, what he still needed to work on, what his strengths were. It was a wonderful experience and I have precious memories.

555:43:27

SUZANNE MAYES: I'm going to show you an item and ask you if you recognize it. It's State's 237.

565:43:32

JANET RICARD: Yes, ma'am.

575:43:33

SUZANNE MAYES: Does it bear your initials?

585:43:36

JANET RICARD: Yes, ma'am.

595:43:37

SUZANNE MAYES: This would be 237 for evidence.

605:43:40

ROBERT MADSEN: No objection.

615:43:41

THE COURT: 237 without objection. (WHEREUPON, State's Exhibit number 237 was admitted into evidence.)

625:43:48

SUZANNE MAYES: And Ms. Muran, was she first grade?

635:43:49

JANET RICARD: Ms. Muran was first grade, yes, ma'am.

645:43:52

SUZANNE MAYES: And did you have occasion to work one-on-one with Eli as part of that project you just mentioned?

655:43:58

JANET RICARD: I did. And that was part of what the course work required. Multiple times, I had to remove him from the classroom and we would go either out into the hallway or sometimes to my office or to another space just so we could have some quiet workspace. And he would sometimes choose books to bring to read. Sometimes it might be a situation where I just asked him questions about reading and about how he felt about reading, if he thought he was a good reader. So, really, just taking the time to get to know him as a reader and where he was in his reading process and how he was developing as a reader. And I got to know a lot about him personally, too.

665:44:43

SUZANNE MAYES: Did he appear to enjoy that time?

675:44:45

JANET RICARD: Oh, he loved it. He looked forward to it. And it was -- he always lit up when I would come to the door to get him. We both looked forward to it. (WHEREUPON, video played for the jury starting at 3:00 p.m. and ended at 3:05 p.m.)

685:50:10

SUZANNE MAYES: Ms. Ricard, did that video adequately depict the unique characteristics of Eli Jones?

695:50:17
705:50:23

SUZANNE MAYES: My last question to you is about you personally. Being someone who had a direct relationship with the children, how did these crimes impact you personally?

715:50:36

JANET RICARD: They still impact me.

SUZANNE MAYES: Thank you, Ms. Ricard.

CrossCrossJanet Ricard — Cross Janet Ricard Robert Madsen

CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MR. MADSEN:

ROBERT MADSEN: Ms. Ricard, I want to show you what's been marked as Defense for ID 301, 302, 303 and 304. Take a look at that. Would that have been at school?

755:52:43

JANET RICARD: Yes, this was in Fran's classroom whenever Merah was in first grade. And then this would have been -- this was actually right out at the crosswalk. I'm assuming that would have been when Nahtahn was in kindergarten, but I'm not positive. But they were, obviously, already in school. That's Nahtahn and Mr. Jones. That would have been at a school function, obviously, around Thanksgiving. They always do the Thanksgiving play, so that would have been kindergarten year. And then this -- this could have been a family night. I'm not positive. It looks like it was in Ms. Muran's room, so it would have been when -- it would have been when Eli was in first grade. I recognize some of the other students, so that would have been first grade year for Eli.

765:53:37

ROBERT MADSEN: Judge, we would move Defendant's 301 through 304 into evidence.

775:53:49

SUZANNE MAYES: No objection.

785:53:52

THE COURT: 301, 302, 303, 304 for the defense, all without objection. (WHEREUPON, Defendant's Exhibit numbers 301 through 304 were admitted into evidence.)

795:54:35

ROBERT MADSEN: Okay. 301 is, I think you said Ms. Lee?

805:54:40

JANET RICARD: That was Ms. Lee with Merah, so that would have been at some point during Merah's first grade year.

815:54:50

ROBERT MADSEN: And 302 are the children in kind of, I guess, the crosswalk?

825:54:53

JANET RICARD: Right, right at the front of the school. And like I said, it's either Nahtahn's kindergarten year or may have been prior to him being in kindergarten. That one's a little bit difficult for me to tell as far as his age.

835:55:11

ROBERT MADSEN: 303 is Tim and Nahtahn?

845:55:13

JANET RICARD: That is Mr. Jones and Nahtahn. And that would have been Nahtahn's kindergarten year. The little turkey hats, kind of a give away. They always did a kindergarten play.

855:55:27

ROBERT MADSEN: And then 304?

865:55:29

JANET RICARD: That looks like it's Ms. Muran's classroom. And like I said, I recognize some of the other folks and students in there. I'm not sure if that was some type of family night, but that was in Eli's first grade year.

875:55:49

ROBERT MADSEN: That's all the questions I have.

885:55:51

THE COURT: Anything else, Ms. Mayes?

895:55:56

SUZANNE MAYES: No, sir, Your Honor.

905:56:02

THE COURT: You may step down.

915:56:07

SUZANNE MAYES: The State calls Joy Lorick.

Continue to next page12.Joy Lorick — Direct/Cross (Recall)