Skip to content
2019 Murder Trialtrial-daytrial-dayShawn GrahamRick HubbardSuzanne MayesRobert MadsenCasey SecorBoyd YoungAdam CreechBhushan AgharkarApril HamesEric Brenton SadreameliMicah SuttoncrossredirectrecrossdirectDay 18 - May 23, 2019Defense witnesses addressed Jones's mental-health history, counseling, religious practice, and house materials; the court deferred a ruling on a video of his mother.
← Day 172019 Murder TrialDay 19 →

Day 18 - May 23, 2019

Mental-Health Testimony and Video Publication Hearing

Judge Eugene C. Griffith, Jr.
15Proceedings
6Pages
5Witnesses
1,700Lines
2Sidebars
Day 18 of 32
Appearing:

Defense witnesses addressed Jones's mental-health history, counseling, religious practice, and house materials; the court deferred a ruling on a video of his mother.

Full day summary

For Day 18, the defense continued presenting testimony about Timothy Jones's mental health, religious beliefs, counseling history, and materials from the South Lake Drive house. Sergeant Adam Creech completed his testimony, including accounts of Jones's interviews and cooperation with investigators; the court reaffirmed its exclusion of five autopsy-room photographs and admitted State's Exhibit 145 subject to an earlier objection. Dr. Bhushan Agharkar, qualified in adult and forensic psychiatry, testified that his assessment found schizophrenia and a minor neuro-cognitive disorder. On cross-examination, he said he was not offering an opinion on criminal responsibility or whether Jones knew right from wrong at the time of the killings. The court marked his materials list and report for identification rather than admitting them as defense exhibits. Pastor Micah Sutton described Jones's intense, literal religious practice and periods of difficult communication. Marriage and family therapist April Hames described counseling Jones in 2012 and 2013, including marital distress and her assessment after he reported wanting to strangle Amber. She said he did not endorse a plan or timeline to harm her. The State questioned Hames about the absence of psychotic symptoms she observed during treatment, while she later testified that schizophrenia symptoms may sometimes be masked depending on their severity. The court also heard identification testimony about materials brought from the South Lake Drive house. At the close of the day, the court excused the jury while it reviewed a video of Jones's mother, Cynthia Turner. The video and a New York order were marked for identification only, and the court deferred its ruling on publication.

Video thumbnail9:59:50
Watch →

5. April Hames — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Recross

April Hames described counseling Tim Jones for marital distress and depression, then answered questions about the absence, masking, and possible faking of psychotic symptoms.

Direct
April Hames — Direct April Hames Boyd Young
241 lines

April Hames described counseling records concerning Tim's marital distress, parenting, reported mental-health symptoms, and diagnostic codes; Defense Exhibit 134 was admitted.

Cross
April Hames — Cross April Hames Shawn Graham
230 lines

Hames testified that she observed no delusions or hallucinations during counseling of Tim Jones, was qualified as an expert, and discussed her custody affidavit.

Redirect
April Hames — Redirect April Hames Boyd Young
42 lines

Hames gave qualified testimony on brain-injury limits, reported reconciliation discussions, and the possible masking of schizophrenia symptoms.

Recross
April Hames — Recross April Hames Shawn Graham
5 lines

Hames agreed that schizophrenia symptoms can be faked.

← Day 172019 Murder TrialDay 19 →