Skip to content
2019 Murder Trialtrial-daytrial-dayShawn GrahamRick HubbardRobert MadsenCasey SecorBoyd YoungErin BiglerBrian TravisRoberta ThornsberrydirectcrossredirectrecrossDay 19 - May 24, 2019The court ruled on a Turner video and limits on proposed testimony as the defense presented neuropsychology, family-history, and cell-phone timeline evidence.
← Day 182019 Murder TrialDay 20 →

Day 19 - May 24, 2019

Brain-Injury Testimony, Family History, and Cell-Phone Timeline

Judge Eugene C. Griffith, Jr.
12Proceedings
6Pages
3Witnesses
1,878Lines
Day 19 of 32
Appearing:

The court ruled on a Turner video and limits on proposed testimony as the defense presented neuropsychology, family-history, and cell-phone timeline evidence.

Full day summary

The court excluded a video of Ms. Turner from jury viewing during the defense case, while allowing experts to reference it and retaining it as Court's Exhibit 90. Defense neuropsychologist Erin Bigler testified about MRI findings he associated with an old traumatic brain injury and discussed possible effects on executive function, emotional regulation, cognition, and behavior. On cross-examination and recross, he described limits on what imaging could establish, including causation, legal responsibility, and diagnosis without clinical evaluation. Roberta Thornsberry testified about her observations of Timothy Jones Jr.'s early family environment, childhood behavior, later religious focus, and a 2014 Atlanta visit that concerned her. The court limited portions of her proposed testimony, and family photographs and an Atlanta-trip video were admitted. Brian Travis presented a defense timeline compiled from cell-phone data, receipts, and bank records, later clarifying a location as somewhere in Charleston County. On cross-examination, the court limited his expert testimony to electronic-device data, admitted the State's timeline, and excluded its related map because it had not been provided earlier.

Video thumbnail8:59:50
Watch →

1. Jury-Security Matters and Turner Video Ruling

Before the jury entered, the court addressed juror-security procedures and ruled the jury would not see the Ms. Turner video.

Procedural
Jury-Security Matters and Turner Video Ruling
66 lines

The court addressed juror security, excluded the Turner video from jury viewing while permitting expert reference to it, and noted the defense's preserved objection.

2. Erin Bigler — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Recross

Defense neuropsychologist Erin Bigler testified about MRI findings he associated with an old traumatic brain injury, while acknowledging that imaging alone could not determine causation, legal awareness, or diagnose schizophrenia.

Direct
Erin Bigler — Direct Erin Bigler Boyd Young
134 lines

Neuropsychologist Erin Bigler testified that MRI scans showed traumatic brain injury and brain abnormalities he associated with effects on behavior and emotional regulation.

Cross
Erin Bigler — Cross Erin Bigler Rick Hubbard
127 lines

Erin Bigler said brain imaging could show injury and increased risk factors but could not diagnose schizophrenia, explain the killings, or answer whether Mr. Jones knew right from wrong.

Redirect
Erin Bigler — Redirect Erin Bigler Boyd Young
44 lines

Bigler said a revised hypothetical involving family history, scan findings, and auditory hallucinations was consistent with schizophrenia, while qualifying that diagnosis is usually collaborative.

Recross
Erin Bigler — Recross Erin Bigler Rick Hubbard
27 lines

Bigler agreed that clinical assessment is needed alongside imaging when evaluating self-reported symptoms; the court then admitted Defendant's Exhibit 137 and ordered a proffer.

5. Roberta Thornsberry — Direct/Cross/Redirect (Part 2)

Roberta Thornsberry described family history and a 2014 Atlanta visit that concerned her, while cross-examination addressed Tim's apparently happy behavior there and unanswered calls before Labor Day.

Direct
Roberta Thornsberry — Direct Roberta Thornsberry Casey Secor
340 lines

Roberta Thornsberry described the defendant's childhood, family history, and later religious focus, then identified family photographs and an Atlanta video admitted for the jury.

Cross
Roberta Thornsberry — Cross Roberta Thornsberry Shawn Graham
236 lines

Roberta Thornsberry said she had not known of mental-health treatment or reports of voices, and described her alarm when Tim stopped answering calls before a planned family visit.

Redirect
Roberta Thornsberry — Redirect Roberta Thornsberry Casey Secor
30 lines

Thornsberry described a troubled 2012 visit and later phone contact with Timmy.

6. Brian Travis — Direct/Cross

Brian Travis testified about cell-phone and financial records used to trace reported movements and activity; the court admitted the records but excluded a related map.

Direct
Brian Travis — Direct Brian Travis Robert Madsen
155 lines

Cellular analyst Brian Travis explained a defense timeline built from phone, receipt, and bank records; Defense Exhibit 212 was admitted without objection.

Cross
Brian Travis — Cross Brian Travis Shawn Graham
442 lines

The court limited Brian Travis's expert testimony to electronic-data analysis as he used phone, bank, and receipt records to trace a detailed travel timeline.

← Day 182019 Murder TrialDay 20 →