8.Amber Kyzer — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Recross (Recall)
138 linesAMBER KYZER, being first duly sworn, testified as follows:
COURT CLERK: Have a seat, please, ma'am. Once you're seated, state your full name, spelling your last.
AMBER KYZER: Amber Kyzer, K-Y-Z-E-R.
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. YOUNG:
BOYD YOUNG: Amber, who are you here for?
AMBER KYZER: I'm here for my babies.
BOYD YOUNG: Did your kids love their dad?
AMBER KYZER: Yes, they did.
BOYD YOUNG: Can you tell the jury a little bit about your and Tim's relationship and how it was?
AMBER KYZER: In the beginning, Tim and I had a very strong relationship. I think we found a lot in common. I wasn't speaking to my family at the time and I'm not sure if he was really speaking to his at the time when we first met. And we just kind of latched onto each other. Later on, any little thing would kind of spark an argument and our relationship became volatile, not just on Tim's side, on mine as well. It got aggressive at times, violent, but we managed to stick through it because we had the children. Towards the end of our marriage, I think I was thinking the best interest for my children that it was not a good environment, it was not something that children needed to be seeing, so we separated ourselves. Tim initially left me and turned my power off and stuff. And I found it really hard because I just had nothing to offer my children. I could not provide for them. I think as a mother, I was making the best choice that I could. I trusted my husband at the time because he gave me no reason not to with my children. He was a good father while we were married. He promised to take care of them. We coparented pretty good towards the end. I think that's what took me back a little bit. I'm really sorry that everybody has to sit here for this. I don't think anybody saw this coming. And I know between myself and members of the Jones family themselves, I know if anybody had seen anything that any of us, any one of us would have done something about it so we wouldn't be in this position today.
BOYD YOUNG: Did you love Tim?
AMBER KYZER: I did. I did. And I'd be lying if I sat here and said that everything in our marriage was bad. Tim and I had a lot of good times. Just becomes a point when things are volatile that you just make a choice where young children aren't seeing certain things. It's affecting them at a point and you make a choice to separate yourself from that person. And it's hard to separate yourself from that person because that's all you've known. All I knew from 19 was Tim.
BOYD YOUNG: Do you want Tim put to death?
AMBER KYZER: I personally, myself, can't bring myself to want anybody to die. It's a really hard -- I hear what my kids went through -- I'm just being honest. I hear what my kids went through and what they endured -- I'm sorry. And as a mother, if I could personally rip his face off, I would. That's the mom in me. That's the momma bear in me wanting to just make him feel everything they felt. I don't personally feel like I have the right to put anybody's life in my hands. I don't wish that upon anybody. I don't wish the Jones family to feel what I felt losing my sons. I do not wish that. I will never have my grandbabies. I will never have any of those things. They'll never get to see anything more of them. I'm trying to, I guess, take a step back and try and put myself in everybody's shoes because it has affected a lot more than just myself. It's even affected you guys. And you're just getting to know them. There's so much more about them. It's affected more than just me.
I pray for Tim all the time. I pray for him often. I pray for his family often. I pray for my family. They never had the opportunity to know them. I can't bring myself to want anybody to die. That's something that I say because I have to be okay with what I say on this stand. This is something I have to live with. There's been a lot of loss on both sides of our families. Since kids have died, I've lost 11 family members, if you include my children, within the past five years. One being an aunt that died the first day trial started of kidney failure. I've had many, many losses in pregnancy. I had eight babies all together with Tim, eight. I had five healthy, two miscarriages and a stillborn daughter and now, I have none of them. That is a lot of loss for a mother to feel. So I do sympathize with Ms. Roberta, I do. I thank her and I connected on that when I was involved with the Jones family.
BOYD YOUNG: Do you want mercy for Tim?
AMBER KYZER: I do. And I don't say it lightly. He did not show my children mercy by any means. But my kids loved him and if I'm speaking on behalf of my kids and not myself, that's what I would have to say. I'm not here for me. The mom in me just wants him to feel everything that I feel, that my kids felt. Nothing justifies, nothing justifies what you've done. There's nothing you could possibly say that would justify what you've done to my babies, but they loved you. I loved you. I thought if we could reach a point to make things work for our children that we could. And then we'd argue again and I'd say there's the Tim, there's the Tim that I can't be with. It wasn't a game. It was a legitimate back and forth fight emotionally. I hope for mercy for you. I pray for you often. And I say that without excusing what he's done. I say that wholeheartedly from the depths of my soul. I don't want anyone to feel any more -- there's been so much loss, a lot of loss.
BOYD YOUNG: Thank you, Amber. Please answer any questions the State has.
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MS. MAYES:
SUZANNE MAYES: Amber, you've been through so much. There's no possible way you could ever put it into words, is there?
AMBER KYZER: No, ma'am.
SUZANNE MAYES: You could sit here all day today and all day tomorrow and still not spill out all of the contents of your heart?
AMBER KYZER: Yes, that's true.
SUZANNE MAYES: Those five beautiful souls you had, they're irreplaceable?
AMBER KYZER: They are. I have a three-year-old that looks identical to Merah, identical, but she's not Merah.
SUZANNE MAYES: She's not.
AMBER KYZER: No.
SUZANNE MAYES: And you haven't been able to be in the courtroom, but you've been watching all of this, haven't you, so that you could keep up?
AMBER KYZER: I have. I have watched every bit of this unfold.
SUZANNE MAYES: And all of those unique, special, undeniable characteristics that you heard about the kids --
AMBER KYZER: Yes.
SUZANNE MAYES: -- those are all true and more, aren't they?
AMBER KYZER: Oh, yes, and so much more about them. I think Tahn made his presence known when Woody started talking.
SUZANNE MAYES: You said a little while ago that the decisions you made were because "I had nothing to offer my children". And that might be true financially, but you had a lot more to offer them, didn't you? Love?
AMBER KYZER: I did. I didn't have physical means, but I -- they were very loved. And this is something I tell my kids every night, I do. I told them -- I talked to them on the phone and I mean it. My kids were wanted, they are loved and they are important. They are loved, they are wanted and they are important. Always. I've always wanted them, I've always loved them. I never told them that I didn't want them.
SUZANNE MAYES: So when we talk about that love and care that you had to offer them, that's eternal?
AMBER KYZER: Yes, it is.
SUZANNE MAYES: And even when you physically left the residence, he knew you still loved and cared for your children, didn't he?
AMBER KYZER: He did. He did know.
SUZANNE MAYES: He knew that on August 28th of 2014, didn't he?
AMBER KYZER: He did.
SUZANNE MAYES: I want to talk with you a little about what led you here today to testify in this phase. Of course, you testified in the guilt phase because you had direct knowledge of what happened on the night of August 28th?
AMBER KYZER: Yes, ma'am.
SUZANNE MAYES: You were the last person to speak with Nahtahn?
AMBER KYZER: Yes.
SUZANNE MAYES: But what led you here today is I think you got a subpoena?
AMBER KYZER: Yeah, to be here. It was from yesterday. I was called to be here.
SUZANNE MAYES: And you were called by Tim's attorneys to be here?
AMBER KYZER: Uh-huh.
SUZANNE MAYES: Really, to state what you've always felt. That you don't want to be the one to decide what should happen to someone?
AMBER KYZER: Yeah. That's why we have the jury.
SUZANNE MAYES: And part of what goes into that, just making sure that it's conveyed accurately, is in a case like this, it's the jury that decides the sentence?
AMBER KYZER: It is.
BOYD YOUNG: Objection, form of the question.
THE COURT: Rephrase your question.
SUZANNE MAYES: The State has never asked you or requested you to take a position on this, right?
AMBER KYZER: No. No.
SUZANNE MAYES: And --
AMBER KYZER: And I need the Jones family to know that at the end, this is not my choice. This is not my choice. And I respect whatever choice you make. I need you guys to know that.
SUZANNE MAYES: So really, Amber, that's what I want to ask about a little bit more. With the State seeking the death penalty, the State has never asked you to take a position one way or another, correct?
AMBER KYZER: No, you haven't.
SUZANNE MAYES: And you respect the State's right to seek the death penalty in this case?
BOYD YOUNG: Objection,--
THE COURT: I'll allow that question. I sustained the first one for the record. This one I'll allow.
SUZANNE MAYES: You respect the State's right to seek the death penalty in this case?
AMBER KYZER: I do. I just can't.
SUZANNE MAYES: You don't want to be the one who would have to make that decision?
AMBER KYZER: Right, I can't make that decision.
SUZANNE MAYES: And we've never ask that of you, have we?
AMBER KYZER: No.
SUZANNE MAYES: And I think you said a few moments ago that as a mother, your feelings might be different when you think in terms of being a mom?
AMBER KYZER: I think any mother would. I think any mother would want to shred the face off of anybody who would harm her children, absolutely. Yes, that would be the mom in me.
SUZANNE MAYES: And the mom in you is part of you, will always be part of you?
AMBER KYZER: Uh-huh.
SUZANNE MAYES: The mom in you has had a lot of conflicted feelings about what should happen to Tim?
AMBER KYZER: Yes. I spoke very openly about that. I didn't get the chance just to kind of give a little -- I didn't have the chance to hear everything that had happened to my children, what literally happened to them or what happened that night, the things that led up to this, I wasn't aware of fully. So I was finding out along with you guys and the world what had happened to my children. So in retrospect, the mom in me was like fry him, fry him. Absolutely. But from the beginning, I have maintained that I -- I just -- I am not a death penalty -- I don't -- I'm a strong believer in no death penalty. But yes, I have had conflicting, very conflicting opinions with that with regards to what had happened to my children. Yes, naturally.
SUZANNE MAYES: You spoke a little bit a few moments ago about some of the violence. There was an incident here in Lexington County, I believe, that you actually reported to the police?
AMBER KYZER: Would it be the 18-wheeler?
SUZANNE MAYES: Uh-huh. Can you tell us about that?
AMBER KYZER: Tim and I were leaving Wal-Mart and we had gotten into an argument and he said hey, let's just play chicken then. You know, in a more stern, argumentative tone. And I said, Tim, it's not funny, it's not F'ing funny. It's not F'ing funny. We had the kids in the back seat. So an 18-wheeler was coming this way and Tim steered the car where the 18-wheeler would hit me directly. And as we were driving toward the 18-wheeler -- I mean, it wasn't much of a distance at all and Tim jerked the car that way and just started laughing about it like it was funny. And I know he remembers that one. And I did report that. It scared me. My children were in the car. Had that 18-wheeler hit, it would have killed -- it would have killed everybody in the car.
SUZANNE MAYES: Is that the only incident that happened during the marriage?
AMBER KYZER: No.
SUZANNE MAYES: Were there times he laid hands on you physically?
AMBER KYZER: Yes.
SUZANNE MAYES: And you have since informed law enforcement about those times as well, correct?
AMBER KYZER: I did. One incident, in particular, we were arguing. I can't remember what it was about. But Tim grabbed me by the side of my head and head butted me to the point where I just blanked out. And when I got up, it was just kind of what just happened. But I could feel my head kind of jar -- my brain jar in my skull. Shortly after that, he threw a phone at my face and broke my back teeth out.
SUZANNE MAYES: How much of that did the children witness?
AMBER KYZER: You know, I'd like to say none of it. My daughter -- my oldest two probably witnessed the most. Merah witnessed a lot of Tim spitting in my face. I was always a whore. Spitting in my face. And I'm not talking about (indicated), I'm talking like hocking loogies and spitting them in my face. He would take me by the side of my hair and smack my head as hard as he could off the car window. Or while I was pregnant, we would be arguing in the car and he would stomp the brake to where the belt would just tighten around my stomach. He would -- the verbal abuse was always that he would chop me up and feed me to the pigs because pigs will eat everything on me but my teeth and I'll never be found.
SUZANNE MAYES: So what you just described, did that contribute to you leaving the marriage?
AMBER KYZER: It did. You know, I think when you're in a situation, when you're in a marriage -- and it was volatile both ways. I'm not going to sit here and lie and sugar coat it and pretend that I was this innocent woman. When you're in a relationship and it's like a tornado and hurricane and it's like a head-on collision, there's no coming down from there. There just isn't. It escalated more when we got here and I think losing the Jones -- we would go the Jones family's residence, his dad's residence, every Saturday, I believe, to have family dinners. That was my break out of my home. And I would vent to my mother-in-law or just have a moment and cry because that's all I could do. When we got down here, we didn't have that support to just run to. I don't think either of us really knew what to do. I think -- I couldn't get my kids out to go to a park if I wanted to. I was stuck in a home for nine years all the time until we went to his dad's house. And I've got to say, as a woman speaking honestly, it will drive you nuts. It'll just drive you nuts. It's like the homeschooling with Merah and Elias, I'm not a certified teacher, so if my kids weren't up to par with their grades, I just -- I'm not -- I'm not going to pretend to be.
SUZANNE MAYES: The videos, you identified them originally, I believe, in the first phase of this trial. And they have since then been offered into evidence and have been published to the jury. But what can you tell us, Amber, about those videos that we saw that were sent to your phone of Merah and Eli?
AMBER KYZER: At the time that I received those, you know, it crushed my heart because these are my babies. And I had even had a discussion with Tim about those recordings after they were sent. I felt like he was using my kids to manipulate me to come back home. The thing was with my children is my children were still young and they didn't quite grasp what was going on or the volatileness between our marriage, as kids shouldn't. That shouldn't be something that's flashed out to a child. That's something that they should be sheltered from, period. It was getting to a point where I couldn't shelter them from that anymore. So him sending these, it was almost tormenting me. It was like your kids are crying for you and you still won't come back. Why are you making them sit down and record themselves crying like this? Because you're tormenting them, too. And just stop. It was tit for tat back and forth like that constantly. And it was very draining.
I'm not going to sugar coat things to benefit anybody here. I'm just -- that's my feeling on the matter. I knew my kids -- I knew, at least, Merah and Nahtahn wanted to be with me. I didn't miss my visits with my children. I missed maybe two at the end, but I was very adamant about seeing my kids. And when I had the chance, I went to see my kids because Lord knows, I didn't get to see them often. The pictures that you guys saw with Tim holding Gabe, I took those. And it was the last time I saw my children alive physically. I don't know how anybody else sees them, but, to me, Tim was smiling, Gabriel was smiling, all the kids were smiling. There was nothing. I thought we were at a point where we were coparenting just fine. We were meeting. We were communicating. We had our volatile phone conversations regularly, not every night, but it was regularly. On both ends. I was stressed because I was managing at Wal-Mart. He made the schedule and it was like, Tim, I can't get there at this specific time, can you please schedule it for another time? Well, instead of meeting me in Lexington, he'd want me to find a way to get all the way to Bush River Road, but didn't want my now mother-in-law to drive me there knowing I didn't have a license. It was just -- it was impossible. Nothing --
SUZANNE MAYES: Did you feel like he was working with you to make those visits happen?
AMBER KYZER: At times, he did. At times, he did. I'm not going to lie. And, you know, I think his dad and his grandmother would reiterate this, too, though, when you make Tim mad, you make him mad. There's no working with him. There's no in the middle. It's either this or nothing at all. So it was rare that he would work with me on something. I believe he did work with me on letting me take them to Chuckie Cheese and treat them to that. That was special to me because that's something I really wanted to do. I paid for every visit.
SUZANNE MAYES: So the videos that you received, your word earlier was manipulate. You believe you received those to manipulate you into coming back home?
AMBER KYZER: That's how I took it, yes. That's how I took it.
SUZANNE MAYES: When we talk about the character of the Defendant, the character of Timothy Jones, is manipulation a fair way to describe him?
AMBER KYZER: Yeah, it can be. Tim knows how to manipulate. Tim knows how to be stubborn and hard-headed and manipulative, coercive.
SUZANNE MAYES: About Nahtahn --
AMBER KYZER: I think a lot of what my kids may have said was coerced, I really do, because that's not the relationship I had with my children. When my children were with me, there was no problem. There was no problem. My kids, mommy, and ran to me with open arms. I am telling you my kids were as stubborn with me and if they had an issue with me, they wouldn't have ran to me.
SUZANNE MAYES: I believe there is a Defense exhibit, 267, Defense Exhibit 267, a statement from Chrystal Ballentine wherein it's alleged that the Defendant would tell the children that you didn't love them. Were you aware of that behavior?
AMBER KYZER: I was not aware of that. I was not. So when I say, I'm finding stuff out along with you guys, I truly am. I was not aware that my kids felt like I didn't love them. I was not -- because I showed it often. Any time -- I believe as a parent when you are wrong for something, if you expect your child to not lie and tell you the truth and to make things right, I believe as a parent you should do the same. And that has always been my thing with my children. That's why the notes were written to them. I wasn't the only failure in the marriage, but if I hurt my children, and I did, then I need to apologize for it and to address it. So no, I was not aware of them hearing that. I always let them know you are loved, you are wanted and you are important. And I expressed that to them often. My fondest last memory of my son, Nahtahn, was him running to me across -- Tim had just parked in a parking space at Chick-Fil-A. And my son got out of the car and he had a little checkered shirt, which I still have to this day that I can't bring myself to wash because it still smells like him. He had his arms open and just took off in the parking lot saying, Mommy. I said, Whoa, son, you're going to get hit by a car. The tight hug that my son gave me just -- I try to hold onto that because if they died thinking I didn't want them or love them, it's just going to kill me. It just --
SUZANNE MAYES: About Nahtahn, were you aware of any issues that Timothy Jones had regarding Nahtahn?
AMBER KYZER: The two children -- out of all five of my children, the two that I always defended the most, that I found myself having to defend the most were Merah and Nahtahn. Nahtahn, primarily. Tahn did not have a problem expressing his feelings. He was very bold. If you did something, he would very much let you know to your face. You could have a zit and he would let you know that it was ugly and to pop it. That's how upfront he was about his feelings. I think there was some resentment there with Tim. I think there was resentment with my daughter, Merah, and my son, Nahtahn, wanting to be with me, I truly do. I think every parent when you're in that situation where your kids are separated and you're fighting for -- you're vying for attention and their love. You are pick me, pick me. In that situation, I guess I didn't fight hard enough. I didn't feel like putting my kids through this tug of war was going to make it any better. I had my feelings and my opinions of their dad and I felt like when they got older, they'd figure it out for themselves. Tim had other methods of it.
SUZANNE MAYES: And that night, one of the sources of conflict that last night was that you had defended Nahtahn?
AMBER KYZER: Yes, I did. Yes, I did. And he let me know it. Tim let me know it.
SUZANNE MAYES: Amber, his statements to you -- do you recall him making statements that you would never have the children, that they would never live with you?
AMBER KYZER: He had many times, numerous times.
SUZANNE MAYES: He'd made that statement on more than one occasion?
AMBER KYZER: Yes. I would say, Tim, what have I done as a parent? The Court didn't find anything wrong with me as a parent. I had joint custody. I chose as a mother what I thought was the most responsible thing with making him primary custodial parent. I obtained a car. I obtained a license. I got a management job and I got my high school diploma. All to prove to the system that I was a good enough parent. It just wasn't good enough for Tim and it never was going to be good enough for Tim. I didn't have anything to offer. He was very insistent on them not being around Shawn.
SUZANNE MAYES: Shawn being your --
AMBER KYZER: And then I found out about Chrystal.
SUZANNE MAYES: Shawn being your husband?
AMBER KYZER: Uh-huh.
SUZANNE MAYES: Your husband now?
AMBER KYZER: Yes. And he was 24 by the way. He was 24 when we got together, I was 27.
SUZANNE MAYES: When you said you found out about Chrystal, you had not been aware --
AMBER KYZER: No, I was not aware of that. I was not even aware -- currently, I live about five minutes from Tim's old place. And I was not aware that he had had that place set up and had Chrystal living there at all. It was not until the guardian ad litem stepped into the case. We were both equally paying for her, I believe, for her services. And she just -- I said, well, who's watching my kids? You know, I'm a mom, I want to know who's watching my children because this isn't right. You know, if I'm not working, why can't you just drop them with me? I would be willing to meet him and go there, whatever the case is, because they're familiar with me. It gives me a little extra time with them. That wasn't going to happen. That was a problem. Well, that's when I found out about Chrystal and her being involved with -- we were still weren't divorced, so my husband -- and it hit me the wrong way. Here, I'm being accused of sleeping with a 17-year-old boy and it's him that's doing it. You know, I didn't jump into a relationship with Shawn like everybody's proclaiming. That's not how it happened at all. And it's unfair for that to be put out there. Everything -- I feel like everything I am accused of is quite opposite.
SUZANNE MAYES: So the statement --
AMBER KYZER: To make me look like the bad parent.
SUZANNE MAYES: The statements that you would never have the children, Amber, he told you that on more than one occasion?
AMBER KYZER: Yes, ma'am, he did.
SUZANNE MAYES: Nothing further.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. YOUNG:
BOYD YOUNG: Despite everything that you've been through, do you want Tim to be put to death?
SUZANNE MAYES: Asked and answered, Your Honor.
THE COURT: I'll allow it.
AMBER KYZER: No.
BOYD YOUNG: Thank you.
AMBER KYZER: I'll respect whatever the jury decides.
RECROSS-EXAMINATION BY MS. MAYES:
SUZANNE MAYES: And Amber, just to follow-up on that. You're okay that you're not the one making that decision, aren't you?
AMBER KYZER: I am.
SUZANNE MAYES: Nothing further, Your Honor.
THE COURT: You may step down.
SUZANNE MAYES: Your Honor, at this time, may she be excused?
THE COURT: She may. All right. You're going to bring Ms. Grey back?
CASEY SECOR: Yes, sir.
THE COURT: Ms. Grey, remind you you're still under oath. Mr. Secor.